Kantian Ethics and Utilitarianism
Kantian ethics is Kant’s view that
human beings are defined by rationality and autonomy. He says you never use
yourself or someone else simply as a means. Kant feels that forcing someone to
do something is an example of this. Another example would be suicide and drug
addiction because it undermines your rationality and autonomy. Utilitarianism
promotes the idea of doing whatever gives the most amount of pleasure and the
least amount of pain. They want to maximize happiness as much as possible even
if it makes them like an animal.
In my view,
Kant’s view is a more plausible way for human beings to live than the
Utilitarian view. Kant believes in doing what is right and not what simply
makes us feel good. Those can be two completely different things. There are a
lot of things that make us feel good that are no good for us such as too much
alcohol, being unfaithful to a spouse, or drugs just to name a few. No matter
what your view is, Kantian ethics leads a person down a road of self-perfection
and promoting the happiness of other people. That is a good road to be on even
if you can never achieve perfection. There are more examples throughout history
of peopke using Kant’s view and they are considered great human beings.
To use the
Barbara example, all acts that are unethical are wrong. All cheating is
unethical. All cheating is wrong.
You start off strong beginning with what Kantian Ethics are. You could explain why Kant thinks this way with evidence from the book. Maybe you could explain why Utilitarianism is not as plausible in more depth to help anybody who is not in a Philosophy class understand what the difference between the two are. Your Barbara argument is valid and helps provide readers with an understanding about cheating.
ReplyDeleteI agree a lot with your blog seeing as I also chose Kant's Ethics. I would put a bigger emphasis on the autonomy and how Kant's rationality and autonomy can help a perfect self into saying no to such pleasures as drugs and alcohol.
ReplyDelete